Blog Layout

Italian Universities: The Unrecognised Problem

Marino Regini • Nov 22, 2012

Marino Regini writes ...

 

La Statale (University of Milan). Photo Danilo Gioia.

 

As Martin Trow already noticed some forty years ago, universities in the developed world are going through different stages: from “élite institutions” to “mass universities” that allow for “generalized access” to higher education (HE). In most European countries, the main response by governments to this process has been to differentiate their HE systems. A first wave of differentiation occurred in the 1960s-1970s, as a response to the need to accommodate a mass of students with different backgrounds and ambitions: the Polytechnics in the UK and the Instituts universitaires de technologie in France served this purpose. Several Continental-European countries went as far as setting in place a formally “binary” HE system: this was the reason to create “Universities of Applied Sciences” first in Germany and The Netherlands, then in Austria, Switzerland, Belgium. A second wave took place in the late 1990s, when the competitive allocation of research funds as a result of the RAE in the UK or of the Exzellenzinitiative in Germany (soon followed by France) served the same purpose.

In Italy, on the other hand, the various governments’ response to the growing demand for tertiary education has not been differentiation, but chaotic expansion of the old élite university, required to perform new functions. Actually, as elsewhere in Europe, in the 1960s there was an attempt by the “Commissione Ermini” and the “Gui bill” to introduce a distinction between universities, entitled to issue degrees from diploma up to dottorato , and newly-established istituti aggregati , with only first-level degree-awarding powers. But this attempt failed for both ideological reasons and the opposition of non-tenured university professors who feared a career within lower status HE institutions.

So Italy has today the only formally “unitary” HE system in Europe, and the myth of a  homogeneous system is still alive. Of course the quality of teaching and research activities differs widely among the almost 90 Italian universities, but they cannot openly compete for staff and students, and the degrees they issue legally have the same value. The lack of a differentiated and competitive system is the key factor that accounts for several of the most cited shortcomings of Italian universities, from clientelistic recruitment to the mismatch between curricula and labour market demands. It is also one of the most important, though largely overlooked, reasons for the rather poor performance of Italian universities in the international rankings, that no governmental reforms so far have even tried to address.

One reason for governments’ disregard of this problem is that differentiation in Italy is a politically sensitive issue because it tends to coincide with the traditionally strong territorial divide. If we take the position in these international rankings as an indicator, however poor and methodologically biased, of universities’ reputation and performance, this divide shows up vividly: out of the 14 Italian universities that are present in at least 3 of the 4 major rankings, only 1 is in the South, although Southern universities account for 31.8% of all HE institutions in Italy.

Another reason is that the prevailing ideology in both left-wing and right-wing parties tends to emphasise “good average quality” of HE institutions over “excellence” of just a few of them. Consider the position of European universities in the Taiwan ranking 2011 (less known than the others but more appropriate here because it is based solely on research performance):

  • only one Italian university is among the top 100 as against two French and eight British universities
  • however, 34.1% of all Italian universities are among the top 500 universities in the world, as against only 26.5% of all French and 27.3% of all British universities.

This means that in Italy good scientific performance is not concentrated in a few excellent institutions (top 100), but relatively diffuse in about 1/3 of them (in the top 500).

Is a HE system that features good universities on average but no internationally excellent ones fit for a country that aims to remain among the most technologically advanced ones? It would be good if policy-makers started at least asking this question, not to say providing a satisfactory answer.

04 Mar, 2024
Open until 14 April 2024, the exhibition Emerging From Darkness: Faith, Emotion and The Body in the Baroque is presented at Victoria's Hamilton Gallery (on the unceded lands of the Eastern Maar and Gunditjmara peoples), in partnership with the National Gallery of Victoria (NGV). Unprecedented, and monumental in scope, Emerging From Darkness brings together an exceptional group of works from public and private collections in Australia. It was curated by Associate Professor David R. Marshall , Principal Fellow in Art History at the University of Melbourne, Dr Lisa Beaven , Adjunct Senior Research at La Trobe University, and Laurie Benson , Senior Curator of International Art at the NGV. Here two curators explain some of the project’s background and aims.
27 Oct, 2023
In Italy this year there has been no shortage of Manzoni celebrations, particularly in Milan . And in Australasia? Dr Stefano Bona , Lecturer in Italian Studies at Flinders University, Adelaide, on the lands of the Kauna nation, has lately been involved in creating a ‘special miniseries’ of radio programmes about Alessandro Manzoni. Now available for listening on demand are two longform interviews with Stefano Pratola at Radio Italiana 531 AM. Here Stefano Bona shares some background to this podcast project.
14 Sep, 2023
Announcing, with great pleasure, the winners of the 2023 ACIS Publication Prize for an established scholar, and the 2023 Jo-Anne Duggan Prize. ACIS awards both prizes every two years . In this case, each winning publication addresses the theme of mobility – a fast-evolving direction in Italian Studies research – and each brings forward a topic with clear contemporary significance.
04 Sep, 2023
The 12th Biennial Conference of the Australasian Centre for Italian Studies will be held at the Australian National University (ANU), Canberra, Ngunnawal and Ngambri Country, from Wednesday 3 July to Saturday 6 July 2024. The conference theme is ‘Italian Studies for Global Challenges: Transdisciplinary Conversations’.
24 Aug, 2023
Open to postgraduate and early career researchers, since 2018 the ACIS Save Venice Fellowship programme has been enlivening close links between Australasia and the city of Venice. Fellowship applications were suspended in 2022, for pandemic-related reasons. So it is a special pleasure to announce that Brigette De Poi has been awarded an ACIS Save Venice Fellowship for 2023. Already living in Venice to focus on her PhD project, Brigette shares some first reflections on her contact with Save Venice thus far.
08 Aug, 2023
Which memories are allowed to circulate in a particular culture – and which are relegated or silenced? What political logic is at play when a certain way of remembering is spelt out, even imposed? Matthew Topp was awarded an ACIS Postgraduate Scholarship in 2020, to source archival records for his doctoral thesis, which has the working title ‘ Ars Oblivionalis : A Study of Cultural Forgetting in Renaissance Italy’. Now returned from fieldwork, he shares a brief account of his PhD project and travels.
By Catherine Kovesi 02 Apr, 2023
Two promising early career scholars – Lauren Murphy and Julia Pelosi-Thorpe – were the recipients of ACIS Save Venice Fellowships. Delayed due to COVID travel restrictions, they were finally able to access their Fellowships in 2022. Here they both reflect on their time in Venice and the benefits of the Fellowship to their respective research projects.
By Catherine Kovesi 29 Mar, 2023
ACIS is delighted to announce that Professor Andrea Rizzi has been appointed the new Chair of the Australasian Centre for Italian Studies. He leads a renewed Management Committee with several new appointees who start their terms of office this year.
By Catherine Kovesi 30 Jan, 2023
After a hiatus of three years due to travel restrictions, ACIS is delighted once again to be able to offer its Postgraduate Scholarships for Research in Italy. Two promising postgraduate students have been awarded scholarships in the current round: Brigette De Poi and Laura Di Blasi.
Show More
Share by: